In our 5-Star Buys series we spotlight popular Etsy items that recently struck a chord with shoppers—and let their rave reviews do the talking.

Dad may be content to carry around his cash and cards (and that slowly disintegrating copy of your first-grade school photo) in an off-the-shelf billfold, but doesn’t he deserve better? This Father’s Day, consider this heirloom-quality alternative: a made-to-order wallet from Kingsley Leather, crafted from vegetable-tanned leather, saddle-stitched by hand in your choice of eight thread shades, and burnished at the edges for extra durability. With any luck, it’ll stand by him as long as he’s stood by you. Take it from this gift giver (and repeat customer in the making):

“Everything about Kingsley’s wallet is exquisite—the craftsmanship, attention to detail, and packaging. I was so happy with it that I gave the gift much earlier than originally planned. I definitely recommend Kingsley’s shop and would love the opportunity to purchase again.” — NA

Shop more from Kingsley Leather